Latest In

News

Sotomayor’s Opinions in Race Cases Put the ‘Racist’ Claim to Rest

Not content with the right-wing pundits’ method of evaluating Judge Sonia Sotomayor by hurling epithets and baseless accusations against her, Tom Goldstein, the

Jul 31, 2020
227.8K Shares
3M Views
Not content with the right-wing pundits’ method of evaluating Judge Sonia Sotomayor by hurling epithetsand baseless accusations against her, Tom Goldstein, the eminent Supreme Court litigator and editor of SCOTUSblog, has actually done the hard work of reading Sotomayor’s opinions in cases involving race. Here’swhat he found:
Of the 96 cases, Judge Sotomayor and the panel rejected the claim of discrimination roughly 78 times and agreed with the claim of discrimination 10 times; the remaining 8 involved other kinds of claims or dispositions.Of the 10 cases favoring claims of discrimination, 9 were unanimous.(Many, by the way, were procedural victories rather than judgments that discrimination had occurred.)Of those 9, in 7, the unanimous panel included at least one Republican-appointed judge.In the one divided panel opinion, the dissent’s point dealt only with the technical question of whether the criminal defendant in that case had forfeited his challenge to the jury selection in his case. So Judge Sotomayor rejected discrimination-related claims by a margin of roughly 8 to 1.
“Given that record,” writes Goldstein, “it seems absurd to say that Judge Sotomayor allows race to infect her decisionmaking.”
Hajra Shannon

Hajra Shannon

Reviewer
Hajra Shannona is a highly experienced journalist with over 9 years of expertise in news writing, investigative reporting, and political analysis. She holds a Bachelor's degree in Journalism from Columbia University and has contributed to reputable publications focusing on global affairs, human rights, and environmental sustainability. Hajra's authoritative voice and trustworthy reporting reflect her commitment to delivering insightful news content. Beyond journalism, she enjoys exploring new cultures through travel and pursuing outdoor photography
Latest Articles
Popular Articles