New hires face a ton of challenges, from plugging into a new culture and getting on top of new responsibilities to navigating communication channels and keeping information overload at bay. The onboarding process, when done right, provides them with what they need to overcome those challenges. Small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs) that provide an exceptional onboarding process maximize their hiring ROI. “A well-executed onboarding experience signals to employees that your company is competent, intentional, and invested in their success,” says Jared Navarre, founder of Keyni Consulting. “When someone feels like there’s a plan for them — and that they’re not being thrown into chaos — they get out of the blocks faster and stick around longer. Morale goes up when people feel confident, not confused.” Navarre is a multidisciplinary founder and creative strategist with a proven track record in launching, scaling, and exiting ventures across IT, logistics, entertainment, and service industries. He has consulted for over 250 businesses, specializing in building operational systems, designing resilient technology infrastructure, and developing multi-platform brand ecosystems that resonate with niche and mainstream audiences alike.
Navarre understands what SMBs gain when they invest in onboarding, as well as the dangers they face when they fail to make it a priority. “Poor onboarding has an impact that goes far beyond simply slowing down the process of plugging in new hires,” he warns. “It quietly erodes your infrastructure until even your best talent can no longer hold the weight.”
Onboarding poses a special challenge to SMBs because employee roles are often less clearly defined than at larger organizations. For example, someone hired to help with marketing at a mid-sized business might also find themselves playing a sales role once their efforts start to bear fruit. Or someone brought in to manage a small office may also be saddled with HR duties.
Companies that leave roles ambiguous will most likely find that their new hires experience confusion, which leads to frustration for both the hires and those managing them. Without clarity, new hires won’t know what target they are shooting for.
“The most important part of onboarding is clarity,” Navarre says. “SMBs must provide it by clearly systematizing job expectations, team norms, and how success is measured. The goal is to remove ambiguity from day one. A new hire should never wonder what their first 30 days are supposed to look, smell, and feel like.” Companies struggling with retention and productivity often assume they have a culture problem. When they hemorrhage employees or watch productivity unravel, they blame it on their failure to create an environment where employees can get excited and get engaged. The reality, however, is that poor onboardingis more often the culprit. “When onboarding doesn’t define roles or outline the operational structure, responsibilities will overlap, ownership will be unclear, and critical tasks will consistently slip through the cracks,” Navarre explains. “New hires won’t be able to get any traction, and the conscientious employees — the ones who pick up the slack — will become overwhelmed, overworked, and eventually walk out the door. A certain amount of friction or redundancy is tolerable and should be expected, especially in SMBs experiencing growth or going through transitions, but every team has a threshold. Push past it, and the dam breaks.”
Employee handbooks are often given to new hires as part of the onboarding process. The standard handbook provides a company overview, outlines employment basics, details policies and procedures, and explains benefits.
Navarre sees employee handbooks as a foundation for solid onboarding, providing an operating system that defines the cultural code, communication norms, decision-making structures, compliance obligations, and a shared language that a business runs on. However, he also says that companies will struggle to achieve onboarding excellence if they don’t go deeper.
“The real magic happens when that foundation provided in handbooks is extended to the individual level through role-specific guides,” Navarre says. “The best onboarding provides job-level handbooks that outline exactly what success looks like in a given position. These aren’t just task lists, but define scope, priorities, recurring responsibilities, handoff points, and KPIs. They also help employees understand how their work fits into the broader system, creating alignment and autonomy at the same time. One Kenyi client saw a 30% boost in retention within six months after replacing vague onboarding with role-based handbooks.”
While the work that goes into developing role-specific guides can be especially challenging for SMBs, the ROI can be well worth the effort. Defining roles with a high level of transparency on paper forces businesses to make informed decisions about their structure, accountability, and operations, providing a firm foundation for growth.
“Businesses that really invest in onboarding systemize clarity, and that’s what scales,” Navarre says. “They create environments where onboarding is faster, delegation is better, and teams are stronger.”